Under the Tuscan Sun - Frances Mayes

A latest trend observed in travel writing is the genre of "villa renovation and restoration" tales. The premise is simple - the author decides to purchase a large and rambling villa (preferably in an exotic location) and then proceeds to renovate and restore it to its original glory together with a commentary on the local populace and the culture. One of the earliest books to explore this idea, "Under the Tuscan Sun" is the story of the struggle of an American family who buy a villa in the picturesque Tuscan countryside and proceed to renovate it to make it a permanent home. The prose is delightfully cheery and upbeat and to the credit of the author, she succeeds in making the dreary job of renovating a house sound like a cheerful year long party. Also, the added descriptions of the Tuscan countryside, the descriptions of Italian customs and traditions and the endless number of excursions, picnics and parties makes for good escapist reading.

However, the very same reasons make this book worthwhile only for a one-time read and prevents it from acquiring the status of a classic. The author fails to inject any humanity into the myriad characters present in this book and none of them stay with you once you've put down the book. This book had the potential to become a classic like 'My Family and other Animals' as the theme of renovating a villa has been explored in the latter as well, but sadly the book fails to reach perfection in terms of character exploration. Still, this is still worth a one-time read especially if you are tired of the drudgeries of city life and want a momentary escape to a quaint and idyllic place.